On the New Concept of the Origin of the Transeurasian or Altaic Languages
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2024.216Abstract
A new concept of the origin of the Altaic languages emerged in foreign publications recently. This concept, based on linguistic, genetic, and archaeological data, linked the ancestral Altaic language to the early farming cultures of the West Liaohe River. It suggests that farmers, speakers of the prospective Tungus-Manchu, Japanese, and Korean languages, spread outside
this area in the eastern direction, whereas pastoralists, speakers of the Turkic-Mongolian languages, moved in the western direction. This article examines the archaeological foundations of the new concept, primarily those related to the Tungus-Manchu languages. According to the authors of the concepts, the Zaisanovkaya Neolithic culture of Primor’e represents the
first Proto-Tungus-Manchu speaking population. They suppose that around 6500–4900 cal. BP these people broke away from the Proto-Tungus-Mongolian Hongshan culture, residing in Western Liaohe, and migrated to South-Central Primor’e, and then, much later, already from there, they spread north to the Amur basin. The idea of localizing the homeland of the Tungus-Manchu languages in the south or in the south of Manchuria is not new and has been expressed earlier. The new concept has introduced new linguistic arguments in favor of this idea. However, the article demonstrates that their attempts to correlate these arguments with archaeological data should be considered unsuccessful. The central theses of the new concept, which connect the spread of the Proto-Tungus-Manchu languages and agriculture, remain unproven, as does their connection precisely to West Liaohe farmers.
Keywords:
Transeurasian (Altaic) languages, Tungus-Manchu languages, archaeology, Neolithic, Zaisanovskaya culture, Hongshan culture
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Литература
Alkin S. V. Drevnie kul’tury Severo-Vostochnogo Kitaia. Neolit Iuzhnoi Manchzhurii. Novosibirsk, Institut arkheologii i etnografii SO RAN Press, 2007, 168 p. (In Russian)
Andreeva Zh. V., Garkovik A. V., Zhushchikhovskaya I. S., Kononenko N. A. Valentin-Peresheek — poselenie drevnikh rudokopov. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1987, 248 p. (In Russian)
Beifudi: a prehistoric site in the Yi River valley, ed. by H. Duan. Beijing, Cultural Relics Publ., 2007, 352 p.
Bettinger R., Barton L., Morgan C. The origins of food production in North China: A different kind of agricultural revolution. Evolutionary Anthropology, 2010, vol. 19, pp. 9–21.
Bettinger R., Barton L., Richerson P., Boyd R., Hui W., Won C. The transition to agriculture in Northwestern China. Developments in Quaternary Science, 2007, vol. 9, pp. 83–101.
Boserup E. The Conditions of Agricultural Growth. London, Allen & Unwin, 1965, 128 p.
Cui Y., Zhang F., Ma P., Fan L., Ning C., Zhang Q., Zhang W., Wang L., Robbeets M. Bioarchaeological perspective on the expansion of Transeurasian languages in Neolithic Amur River basin. Evolutionary Human Sciences, 2020, vol. 2 (15), pp. 1–13.
Derevianko A. P., Cho Iu-Chzhon, Medvedev V. E., Kim Son-Te, Iun Kyn-Il, Khon Khen-U, Chzhun Suk-Be, Kramintsev V. A., Kan In-Uk, Laskin A. R. Otchet o raskopkakh na ostrove Suchu v Ul’chskom raione Khabarovskogo kraia v 2000 godu. Seul, Izdatel’stvo Gosudarstvennogo issledovatel’skogo institute kul’turnogo naslediia Respubliki Koreia Press; Institut arkheologii i etnografii SO RAN Press, 2000, 564 p. (In Russian)
Derevianko A. P., Cho Iu-Chzhon, Medvedev V. E., Iun Kyn-Il, Khon Khen-U, Chzhun Suk-Be, Kramintsev V. A., Medvedeva O. S., Filatov I. V. Issledovaniia na ostrove Suchu v Nizhnem Priamur’e v 2001 g. Seul, Izdatel’stvo Gosudarstvennogo issledovatel’skogo instituta kul’turnogo naslediia Respubliki Koreia Press; Institut arkheologii i etnografii SO RAN Press, 2002. (In Russian)
Drennan R. D., Lu X., Peterson C. A place of pilgrimage? Niuheliang and its role in Hongshan society. Antiquity, 2017, vol. 91 (355), pp. 43–56.
Dybo A. V. Sovremennoe sostoianie issledovanii po ustanovleniiu prarodiny altaiskikh iazykov. Materialy Pervogo mezhdunarodnogo altaisticheskogo foruma “Tiurko-mongol’skii mir Bol’shogo Altaia: Istoriko-kul’turnoe nasledie i sovremennost’”. Barnaul, Altaiskii gosudarstvennyi univesitet Press, 2019, pp. 10–14. (In Russian)
Examining the Farming/Language Dispersal Hypothesis, eds P. Bellwood, C. Renfrew. Cambridge, McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, 2002, 505 p.
Freeman J., Peeples M., Anderies J. Toward a theory of non-linear transitions from foraging to farming. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 2015, vol. 40, pp. 109–122.
Fuller D., Champion L., Stevens C. Comparing the tempo of cereal dispersal and the agricultural transition: two African and one West Asian trajectory. Trees, Grasses and Crops: People and Plants in Sub-Saharan Africa and Beyond. Bonn, Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, 2019, pp. 119–141.
Garkovik A. V. Neoliticheskii keramicheskii kompleks mnogosloinogo pamiatnika Rybak-1 na iugo-zapadnom poberezh’e Primor’ia. Problemy arkheologii i paleoekologii Severnoi, Vostochnoi i Tsentral’noi Azii. Novosibirsk, Institut arkheologii i etnografii SO RAN Press, 2003, pp. 94–101. (In Russian)
Gel’man E. I., Isakova T. V., Vostretsov Iu. E. Keramicheskii kompleks neoliticheskogo poseleniia Zaĭsanovka-7. Arkheologiia i sotsiokul’turnaia antropologiia Dal’nego Vostoka i sopredel’nykh territorii. Blagoveshchensk, Izdatel‘stvo Blagoveshchenskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta Press, 2003, pp. 128–135. (In Russian)
Gel’man E. I., Vostretsov Iu. E. Ornament keramiki poseleniia Zaisanovka-1. Neolit i neolitizatsiia basseina Iaponskogo moria: chelovek i istoricheskii landshaft. Vladivostok, Dal‘nevostochnyi gosudarstvennyi universitet Press, 2008, pp. 49–55. (In Russian)
Girchenko E. A. Kul’tury neolita severo-vostoka Kitaia i ikh sviazi s sopredel’nymi territoriiami (po materialam kitaĭskikh issledovateleĭ). Problemy arkheologii, ėtnografii, antropologii Sibiri i sopredel’nykh territorii, 2019, no. 25, pp. 68–73. (In Russian)
Han M. Prehistoric settlements and environment of West Liaohe River Valley. Chinese Archaeology, 2012, vol. 12, pp. 182–188.
Harris D. An evolutionary continuum of people-plant interaction, Foraging and farming. The evolution of plant exploitation. London, Unwin Hyman, 1989, pp. 11–26.
Istoriia Kitaia s drevneishykh vremen do nachala XXI veka, vol. 1. Moscow, Vostochnaia literatura Publ., 2016, 974 p. (In Russian)
Hosner D., Wagner M., Tarasov P. E., Chen X., Leipe C. Spatiotemporal distribution patterns of archaeological sites in China during the Neolithic and Bronze Age: an overview. The Holocen, 2016, vol. 26 (10), pp. 1576–1593.
Jia P. W. Transition from foraging to farming in Northeast China. Oxford, Archaeopress, 2007, 211 p. (BARIS, vol. 1629).
Jia X., Sun Y., Wang L., Sun W., Zhao Z., Lee H. F., Huang W., Wu S., Lu H. The transition of human subsistence strategies in relation to climate change during the Bronze Age in the West Liao River Basin, Northeast China. The Holocene, 2016, vol. 26 (5), pp. 781–789.
Jia X., Yi S., Sun Y., Wu S., Lee H. F., Wang L., Lu H. Spatial and temporal variations in prehistoric human settlement and their influencing factors on the south bank of the Xar Moron River, Northeastern China. Frontiers in Earth Science, 2017, vol. 11 (1), pp. 137–147.
Kim J., Park J. Millet vs rice: an evaluation of the farming/language dispersal hypothesis in the Korean context. Evolutionary Human Sciences, 2020, vol. 2 (12), pp. 1–18.
Kuchera R. S. Drevneishaia I drevniaia istoria Kitaia: rannii neolit iuga strany. St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoria Publ., 2020, 596 p. (Uchionyie zapiski Otdela Kitaia. Issue 36). (In Russian)
Kuwahata M., Kuriyama Y. Ojiyama ruins. Miyakonojo, Miyakonojo City-Miyazaki Prefecture Press, 2012, 110 p. (Miyakonojo City Cultural Property Survey Report. Vol. 107). (In Japanese)
Leipe C., Long T., Sergusheva E. A., Wagner M., Tarasov P. E. Discontinuous spread of millet agriculture in eastern Asia and prehistoric population dynamics. Science Advances, 2019, vol. 5 (9), eaax6225.
Li T., Ning C., Zhushchikhovskaya I., Hudson M., Robbeets M. Millet agriculture dispersed from Northeast China to the Russian Far East: Integrating archaeology, genetics, and linguistics. Archaeological Research in Asia, 2020, vol. 22, p. 100177.
Liu L., Chen X. The archaeology of China: from the late Paleolithic to the Early Bronze age. New York, Cambridge University Press, 2012, 475 p.
Liu L., Field J., Fullagar R., Bestel S., Chen X., Ma X. What did grinding stones grind? New light on early Neolithic subsistence economy in the Middle Yellow River valley, China. Antiquity, 2010, vol. 84 (325), pp. 816–833.
Liu L., Liu F., Zhang W., Xu Z. Spatial Distribution and Evolution of Ancient Settlements from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age in Dalian Area, China. Frontier in Earth Science, 2022, vol. 10, p. 917520.
Lu P., Chen P., Tian Y., He Y., Mo D., Yang R., Lasaponara R., Masini N. Reconstructing settlement evolution from Neolithic to Shang dynasty in Songshan mountain area of central China based on self-organizing feature map. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2019, vol. 36, pp. 23–31.
Mesoudi A. Cultural evolution. How Darwinian theory can explain human culture and synthesize the social sciences. Rus. ed. Moscow, Izdatel’skii dom “Delo” RANKhiGS Publ., 2019, 384 p. (In Russian)
Moreva O. L., Popov A. N., Fukuda M. Keramika s verevochnym ornamentom v neolite Primor’ia, Arkheologiia i kul’turnaia antropologiia Dal’nego Vostoka i Tsentral’noi Azii. Vladivostok, Dal’nevostochnoe otdelenie RAN Press, 2002, pp. 57–68. (In Russian)
Nelson S., Zhushchikhovskaya I., Li T., Hudson M., Robbeets M. Tracing population movements in ancient East Asia through the linguistics and archaeology of textile Production. Evolutionary Human Sciences, 2020, vol. 2 (5), pp. 1–20.
Ning C., Li T., Wang K., Zhang F., Li T., Wu X., Gao S., Zhang Q., Zhang H., Hudson M., Dong G., Wu S., Fang Y., Liu C., Feng C., Li W., Han T., Li R., Wie J., Zhu Y., Zhou Y., Wang C., Fan S., Xiong Z., Sun Z., Ye M., Sun L., Wu X., Liang F., Cao Y., Wei X., Zhu H., Shou H., Krause J., Robbeets M., Jeong C., Cui Y. Ancient genomes from northern China suggest links between subsistence changes and human migration. Nature Communications, 2020, vol. 11, p. 2700.
Okladnikov A. P. Drevnee poselenie Kondon. Novosibirsk, Nauka Publ., 1981, 160 p. (In Russian)
Robbeets M. Proto-Trans-Eurasian: Where and When? Man in India, 2015, vol. 97 (1), pp. 19–46.
Robbeets M. Austronesian influence and Transeurasian ancestry in Japanese: A case of farming/language dispersal. A case of farming/language dispersal. Language Dynamics and Change, 2017, vol. 7, pp. 210–251.
Robbeets M., Bouckaert R. Bayesian phylolinguistics reveals the internal structure of the Transeurasian family. Journal of Linguistic Evolution, 2018, vol. 3, pp. 145–162.
Robbeets M., Oskolskaya S. Proto-Tungusic in time and space. Tungusic languages: Past and present. Berlin, Language Science Press, 2022, pp. 263–294.
Robbeets M., Bouckaert R., Conte M., Savelyev A., Li T., An D., Shinoda K., Cui Y., Kawashima T., Kim G., Uchiyama J., Dolińska J., Oskolskaya S., Yamano K., Seguchi N., Tomita H. Takamiya H., Kanzawa-Kiriyama H., Oota H., Ishida H., Kimura R., Sato T., Kim J., Deng B., Bjorn R., Rhee S., Ahn K., Gruntov I., Mazo O., Bentley J. R., Fernandes R., Roberts P., Bausch I. R., Gilaizeau L., Yoneda M., Kugai M., Bianco R. A., Zhang F., Himmel M., Hudson M. J., Ning C. Triangulation supports agricultural spread of the Transeurasian languages. Nature, 2021, vol. 599, pp. 616–621.
Savelyev A., Robbeets M. Bayesian phylolinguistics infers the internal structure and the time-depth of the Turkic language family. Journal of Language Evolution, 2020, vol. 5 (1), pp. 39–53.
Sergusheva E., Leipe C., Klyuev N. A., Batarshev S. V., Garkovik A. V., Dorofeeva N. A., Kolomiets S. A., Krutykh E. B., Malkov S. S., Moreva O. L., Sleptsov I. Y., Hosner D., Wagner M., Tarasov P. E. Evidence of millet and millet agriculture in the Far East Region of Russia derived from archaeobotanical data and radiocarbon dating. Quaternary International, 2022, vol. 263, pp. 50–67.
Shin S., Rhee S., Aikens M. Chulmun Neolithic Intensification, Complexity, and Emerging Agriculture in Korea. Asian Perspectives, 2013, vol. 51 (1), pp. 68–109.
Smith B. Low-level food production. Journal of Archaeological Research, 2001, vol. 9 (1), pp. 1–40.
Stevens S., Fuller D. The spread of agriculture in eastern Asia. Archaeological bases for hypothetical farmer/language dispersals. Language Dynamics and Change, 2017, vol. 7, pp. 152–186.
The blade arrowhead cultures over Northeast Asia, ed. by H. Kimura. Sapporo, Sapporo University Press, 1999, 218 p. (Archaeological Series. Vol. 6).
Uchida K., Shevkomud I. Ia., Iamada M., Kunikita D., Gorshkov M. V., Kositsyna S. F., Shapovalova E. A., Imai Ch., Matsumoto T. Rezul’taty issledovaniia poseleniia Bogorodskoe-24 v 2008 godu v Ul’chskom raĭone Khabarovskogo kraia. Arkheologiia CIRCUM-PACIFIC: Pamiati Igoria Iakovlevicha Shevkomuda. Vladivostok, Rubezh Publ., 2017, pp. 112–121. (In Russian)
Vostretsov Iu. E., Gel’man E. I., Komoto M., Miiamoto K., Obata Kh. Novyi keramicheskii kompleks neoliticheskogo poseleniia Krounovka-1 v Primor’e. Problemy arkheologii i paleoėkologii Severnoi, Vostochnoi i Tsentral’noĭ Azii. Novosibirsk, Institut arkheologii i etnografii SO RAN Press, 2003, pp. 86–93. (In Russian)
Wagner M. Neolithikum und fruhe Bronzezeit in Nordchina vor 8000 bis 3500 jahren (Die nordostliche Tiefebene — Sudteil). Mainz, Verlag Philipp von Zabern, 2006, 355 S. (Archaologie in Eurasien. Bd. 21).
Wagner M., Tarasov P., Hosner D., Fleck A., Ehrich R., Chen X., Leipe C. Mapping of the spatial and temporal distribution of archaeological sites of Northern China during the Neolithic and Bronze Age. Quaternary International, 2013, vol. 290–291, pp. 344–357.
Wang C., Lu H., Zhang J., He K., Huan X. Macro-Process of Past Plant Subsistence from the Upper Paleolithic to Middle Neolithic in China: A Quantitative Analysis of Multi-Archaeobotanical Data. PLoS ONE, 2016, vol. 11 (2), e0148136.
Wang C., Lu H., Zhang J., Gu Z., He K. Prehistoric demographic fluctuations in China inferred from radiocarbon data and their linkage with climate change over the past 50,000 years. Quaternary Science Reviews, 2014, vol. 98, pp. 45–59.
Wang C.-C., Robbeets M. The homeland of Proto-Tungusic inferred from contemporary words and ancient genomes. Evolutionary Human Sciences, 2020, vol. 2 (8), pp. 1–12.
Wang C., Yeh H., Popov A., Zhang H., Matsumura H., Sirak K., Cheronet O., Kovalev A., Rohland N., Kim A., Mallick S., Bernardos R., Tumen D., Zhao J., Liu Y., Liu J., Mah M., Wang K., Zhang Z., Adamski N., Broomandkhoshbacht N., Callan K., Candilio F., Duffett Carlson K., Culleton B., Eccles L., Freilich S., Keating D., Lawson A., Mandl K., Michel M., Oppenheimer J., Ozdoğan K., Stewardson K., Wen S., Yan S., Zalzala F., Chuang R., Huang C., Looh H., Shiung C., Nikitin Y., Tabarev A., Tishkin A., Lin S., Sun Z., Wu X., Yang T., Hu X., Chen L., Du H., Bayarsaikhan J., Mijiddorj E., Erdenebaatar D., Iderkhangai T., Myagmar E., Kanzawa-Kiriyama H., Nishino M., Shinoda K., Shubina O., Guo J., Cai W., Deng Q., Kang L., Li D., Li D., Lin R., Nini, Shrestha R., Wang L., Wei L., Xie G., Yao H., Zhang M., He G., Yang X., Hu R., Robbeets M., Schiffels S., Kennett D., Jin L., Li H., Krause J., Pinhasi R., Reich D. Genomic insights into the formation of human populations in East Asia. Nature, 2021, vol. 591, pp. 413–419.
Whitman J., Hudson M. Millets, rice, and farming/language dispersals in East Asia. Language Dynamics and Change, 2017, vol. 7, pp. 147–151.
Yanshina O. V. Problema vydeleniia bronzovogo veka v Primor’e. St. Petersburg, Muzei antropologii i etnografii RAN Publ., 2004, 212 p. (In Russian)
Yanshina O. V. O proiskhozhdenii kul’tur rannego paleometalla Primor’ia. Chetvertye Grodekovskie chteniia. Part 2. Khabarovsk, Khabarovskii kraevoi muzei im. N. I. Grodekova Publ., 2004, pp. 202–207. (In Russian)
Yanshina O. V. Perekhod ot paleolita k neolitu v Kitae. St. Petersburg, Muzei antropologii i etnografii RAN Publ., 2021, 418 p. (In Russian)
Yanshina O. V., Kliuev N. A. Pozdnii neolit i rannii paleometall Primor’ia: kriterii vydeleniia i kharakteristika arkheologicheskikh kompleksov. Rossiiskii Dal’nii Vostok v drevnosti i srednevekov’e: otkrytiia, problemy, gipotezy. Vladivostok, Dal’nauka Publ., 2005, pp. 187–233. (In Russian)
Yuan Y. Cultural evolution and spatial-temporal distribution of archaeological sites from 9.5–2.3 ka BP in the Yan-Liao region, China. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2019, vol. 29 (3), pp. 449–464.
Zhang J., Xia Z., Zhang X., Storozum M., Huang X., Han J., Xu H., Zhao H., Cui Y., Dodson J., Dong G. Early-middle Holocene ecological change and its influence on human subsistence strategies in the Luoyang Basin, North-Central China. Quaternary Research, 2018, vol. 89 (2), pp. 446–458.
Zeder M. The origins of agriculture in the Near East. Current Anthropology, 2011, vol. 52 (S4), pp. 221–232.
Downloads
Published
2024-06-27
How to Cite
Yanshina, O. V. (2024). On the New Concept of the Origin of the Transeurasian or Altaic Languages. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 69(2), 522–544. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2024.216
Issue
Section
Ethnography, Ethnology and Anthropology
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
