From Cyclism to Theologism, or Again about the Peculiarities of Russian History

Authors

  • Andrey Yu. Dvornichenko St. Petersburg State University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2023.214

Abstract

This article was written as a response to the discussion in the previous issue. The concept of the author was regarded by B. N. Mironov as cyclic-pendulum, or inversion nature of Russia’s development. According to it, Russia, unlike the West, is characterized not by progressive, but by spasmodic pendulum development: progress is replaced by reaction, movement goes in a vicious circle. However, this concept is only a part of the whole theory of Dvornichenko, which states, in essence, that the state emerged in the Russian history late, only in 16th century, and in time acquired unique features of state-serfdom system. This system was from time to time disturbed by so called “Smutas” (crises). It is possible to regard these phenomena as cyclic, but it is necessary to take into account that the state after a period of crisis, on the one hand, revives, but on the other hand, there is a tendency towards collapse during such periods and a possibility of the state’s final dissolution. Some neglect of these phenomena in our history
and the desire to study only so-called modernization leads historians to a biased picture of the Russian history, which glosses over the truth. This is evident in the works of B. N. Mironov and his adherents, particularly, in the articles published within the framework of this discussion. One could not overestimate a positive impact of authoritarian power in our history because it is a main cause of every “smuta”. In general, we shouldn’t exaggerate the achievements of the country because the price of every crisis period with the process of demodernization is dear. For the further understanding of the Russian history new and active discussions are necessary.

Keywords:

B. N. Mironov, cyclic-pendulum development, the theory of smutas, modernization, discussions

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

Author Biography

Andrey Yu. Dvornichenko, St. Petersburg State University

Dr. Sci. (History), Professor

References

Литература

Bovykin V. I. Rossiia nakanune velikikh svershenii. K izucheniiu sotsial’no-ekonomicheskikh predposylok Velikoi Oktiabr’skoi sotsialisticheskoi revoliutsii. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1988, 155 p. (In Russian)

Buldakov V. P. Revoliutsiia ili smuta, stabil’nost’ ili zastoi? K itogam stoletnikh nedoumenii. Trudy po rossievedeniiu,2018, no. 7, pp. 23–47. (In Russian)

Cohen S. “Vopros voprosov”: pochemu ne stalo Sovetskogo Soiuza? Moscow, AIRO-XXI Publ., 2022, 216 p.(In Russian)

Davydov M. A. Problemy modernizatsii Rossii: razmyshleniia nad knigoi I. V. Potkinoi. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2023, vol. 68, issue 1, p. 25–50. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Proshchanie s revoliutsiei. Moscow, Ves’ mir Publ., 2018, 272 p. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Rossiia. Zagadka istorii. Moscow, Ves’ mir Publ., 2015, 240 p. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Rossiiskaia istoriia s drevneishikh vremen do padeniia samoderzhaviia. Moscow, Ves’ mir Publ., 2010, 944 p. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Rossiiu ponimat’ umom? Vestnik of Saint Petersburg Universiry. History, 2017, vol. 62, issue 1, pp. 201–214. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Smuta as a Factor of the Russian History. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2018, vol. 63, issue 3, pp. 677–701. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Stalinism, Boyars and the Russian Tradition. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2018, vol. 63, issue 2, pp. 636–647.

Dvornichenko A. Yu. The Place of the Kievan Rus in History. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History,2016, issue 4, pp. 5–16.

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Tsentr i regiony v Rossii pri “starom rezhime”: dialektika razvitiia vzaimootnoshenii.Tsentr i regiony v istorii Rossii: problemy ekonomicheskogo, politicheskogo i sotsiokul’turnogo vzaimodeistviia. St Petersburg, Skifiia-print Publ., 2010 (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Vol. 1), pp. 8–61. (In Russian)

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Why the GDL? Why Musсovy? The Early States of Eastern Europe in Comparative Historical Discourse. Russian History, 2022, no. 48 (2), pp. 129–157.

Dvornichenko A. Yu. Zemskaia i gosudarstvennaia traditsii v istorii dorevoliutsionnoi Rossii. Istoriia. Mir proshlogo v sovremennom osveshchenii. St Petersburg, St Petersburg Universiry Press, 2008, pp. 459–474. (In Russian)

Ermakov V. V. “Maloi krov’iu — moguchim udarom”: 22 iiunia 1941 goda. St Petersburg, Avrora Publ., 2021, 240 p. (In Russian)

Freeze G. L. Imperial Russia as a Failed State: The Role of Orthodox Church. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2023, vol. 68, issue 1, p. 67–81.

Froianov I. Ia. O vozniknovenii russkogo absoliutizma. Froianov I. Ia. Nachala russkoi istorii. Izbrannoe. Moscow, Parad Publ., 2001, pp. 908–919. (In Russian)

Froianov I. Ia. Rossiia. Pogruzhenie v bezdnu. Moscow, Rodina Publ., 2019, 384 p. (In Russian)

Gradovskii A. D. Sobranie sochinenii. Vol. 1. St Petersburg, Tip. M. M. Stasiulevicha Publ., 1899, 421 p. (In Russian)

Horton J. O., Horton L. E. Slavery and Making of America. New York, Oxford University Press, 2005, 256 p.

Limonov V. A. Tsiklichnost’ istoricheskogo protsessa v sotsiologii i filosofii XX veka. Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta kul’tury i iskusstv, 2011, no. 3, pp. 58–64. (In Russian)

Liseitsev D. V. Pochemu Zemskii sobor — ne parlament? Rossiiskaia istoriia, 2020, no. 4, pp. 142–150. (In Russian)

Lizunov P. V. Fondovaia birzha i kommercheskie banki v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2023, vol. 68, issue 1, p. 93–108. (In Russian)

Marchenia P. P. Imperiia kak forma bytiia rossiiskoi tsivilizatsii (k voprosu o mirovozzrencheskikh imperativakh gosudarstvennoi politiki v Rossii). Iuridicheskaia nauka i praktika: Vestnik Nizhegorodskoi akademii MVD Rossii, 2021, no. 1 (53), pp. 315–317. (In Russian)

Marchenia P. P. K voprosu o sootnoshenii kontseptov smuty i revoliutsii v sovremennom otechestvennom sotsiogumanitarnom znanii. Filosofskie issledovaniia i sovremennost’, issue 10. Moscow, IPL Publ., 2021, pp. 87–94. (In Russian)

Marchenia P. P., Razin S. Iu. Imperiia Rossiia: po materialam nauchnogo proekta “Narod i vlast’”. Vesnіk Grodzenskaga dziarzhaunaga unіversіteta іmia Iankі Kupaly. Seryia 1. Gіstoryia і arkhealogіia. Fіlasofіia. Palіtalogіia, 2020, vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 127–136. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Istorik i sotsiologiia. Leningrad, Nauka Publ., 1984, 174 p. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Kul’turnyi kapital Rossii za tysiachu let, Ekonomicheskaia politika, 2013, no. 1, pp. 62–95. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Pogruzivshaia v smutu i ukravshaia pobedu revoliutsiia. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2017, vol. 62, issue 4, pp. 693–716. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Rossiiskaia modernizatsiia i revoliutsiia. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin Publ., 2019, 528 p.(In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Russkaia revoliutsiia 1917 goda v kontekste teorii revoliutsii. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’, 2013, no. 2, pp. 72–84. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Russkaia revoliutsiia 1917 goda v kontekste teorii revoliutsii. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’, 2013, no. 3, pp. 106–115. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Sotsial’naia istoriia Rossii perioda imperii (XVIII — nachalo XX v.), vol. 1. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin Publ., 2003, 548 p. (In Russian)

Mironov B. N. Strasti po revoliutsii. Nravy v rossiiskoi istoriografii v vek informatsii. Moscow, Ves’ Mir Publ., 2013, 336 p. (In Russian)

Moore C. M. States of Welfare: Regulating the Economy in War and Revolution. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2023, vol. 68, issue 1, pр. 82–92.

Nikonov V. A. Rossiiskaia matritsa. Moscow, Russkoe slovo — uchebnik Publ., 2014, 992 p. (In Russian)

Potkina I. V. V preddverii katastrofy. Gosudarstvo i ekonomika Rossii v 1914–1917 godakh. St Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriia Publ., 2022, 380 p. (In Russian)

Povilaitis A. V. Problema iteraktivnosti i tsiklichnosti istoricheskogo protsessa: sotsial’no-filosofskii analiz. Manuskript, 2020, vol. 13, issue 11, pp. 168–174. (In Russian)

Riazanov V. T. Ekonomicheskoe razvitie Rossii. Reformy i rossiiskoe khoziaistvo v XIX–XX vv. St Petersburg, Saint Petersburg University Press, 1998, 796 p. (In Russian)

Rubinshtein N. L. Russkaia istoriografiia. St Petersburg, Saint Petersburg University Press, 2008, 938 p. (In Russian)

Sorokin P. A. Sotsial’naia i kul’turnaia dinamika: issledovanie izmenenii v bol’shikh sistemakh iskusstva, istiny, etiki, prava i obshchestvennykh otnoshenii. St Petersburg, RKhGI press, 2000, 272 p. (In Russian)

Strebkov A. I., Cherezov D. N. K voprosu o lichno-zavisimoi sushchnosti sovremennogo gosudarstva. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University, ser. 6, 2006, issue 3, pp. 87–93. (In Russian)

Tarkovskii A. A. Zagadka Pushkina. Tarkovskii A. A. Stikhotvoreniia raznykh let. Stat’i, zametki, interv’iu. Moscow, Literaturnyi muzei Publ., 2017, pp. 351–355. (In Russian)

Voskresenskaia N. O. O faktorakh padeniia Rossiiskoi imperii i ikh otsenkakh v istoricheskoi nauke. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 2023, vol. 68, issue 1, pр. 51–66. (In Russian)

Zhuravleva V. I. Ponimanie Rossii v SShA: obrazy i mify. 1881–1914. Moscow, RGGU Press, 2012, 1136 p.(In Russian)

Downloads

Published

2023-06-09

How to Cite

Dvornichenko, A. Y. (2023). From Cyclism to Theologism, or Again about the Peculiarities of Russian History. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 68(2), 531–548. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2023.214

Issue

Vol. 68 No. 2 (2023)

Section

Discussions

License

Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.