Imperial Russia as a Failed State: The Role of Orthodox Church
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2023.104Abstract
The purpose of this article is to assess the role of the Orthodox Church during the prelude to the February Revolution. Recent historiography on the Great War in Western scholarship has foregrounded the role of the Churches, Protestant and Catholic, in sustaining popular support for a war that entailed unprecedented death, suffering, and hardship. That new research, seeking to explain the “endurance problem” (Durchhaltsproblem), point to the Churches in the West as the pillar of the existing regimes right to the very end of the war and as an effective instrument in mobilizing support and patriotism to defend each country’s “civilization”. Hence, no less important than brilliant military plans and effective governance, the Churches provided critical support and raised morale of both troops and civilians. Such was not the
case in Russia. With few resources at its disposal, the Orthodox Church provided initial but ephemeral support. As is shown here, the Church was not only unable but unwilling to embrace the ancient regime: against a background of general war weariness, the Church elites, parish clergy, and ordinary parishioners were increasingly determined to pursue their own interests, not those of the state. By February 1917 the Church did not condemn but welcomed the overthrow of the monarchy that ultimately led to the Bolshevik seizure of power and years of brutal civil war. The monograph by I. V. Potkina “On the eve of the catastrophe. The state and the economy in Russia in 1914–1917” has many positive elements, but it is important — given recent historiography, which foregrounds the role of Churches and religion in sustaining society’s willingness to endure the Great War — to pay attention to the role of the Russian Orthodox Church.
Keywords:
Russian Orthodox Church, World War I, Russia Empire, churches, religion, historiography
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Литература
Agapov V. L. Soldatskie pis’ma s fronta Pervoi mirovoi voiny v dal’nevostochnykh gazetakh 1914–1915 gg. Rossiia i ATR, 2015, no. 12, pp. 169–181. (In Russian)
Aksenov V. Narodnaia religioznost’ i obrazy dukhovenstva v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny i revoliutsii. Gosudarstvo,religiia, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2019, no. 1/2, pp. 272–303. (In Russian)
Aristova K. G. Obnovlenchestvo v Penzenskoi eparkhii v 1917–1923 gg. PhD diss. (History). Penza, Penzenskii gosudarstvennyi pedagogicheskii universitet, 2011, 239 p. (In Russian)
Astashov A. B. Prestuplenie i pravo v russkoi armii (1914 — fevral’ 1917 goda). Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, Seriia: Istoriia, 2012, issue 3, pp. 52–67. (In Russian)
Astashov A. B. Propaganda na russkom fronte v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Moscow, Spetskniga Publ., 2012, 400 p. (In Russian)
Astashov A. B. Russkie soldaty i Pervaia mirovaia voina: psikhoistoricheskoe issledovanie voennogo opyta.Sotsial’naia istoriia: ezhegodnik, 2001/2002, pp. 399–426. (In Russian).
Bailey C. E. Gott mit Uns: German’s Protestant Theologians in the First World War. PhD diss. [S. l.], University of Virginia, 1978, 542 p.
Bauernkämpfer A., Julien E. Einleitung: Durchhalten! Kriegskulturen und Handlungspraken im Ersten Weltkrieg. Durchhalten! Krieg und Gesellschaft im Vergleich 1914–1918. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2010, S. 7–30.
Becker A. Faith, Ideologies, and the ‘Cultures of War’. Companion to World War I. Oxford, Blackwell, 2010, pp. 234–247.
Belov S. B. Patriotizm 1914 goda: k voprosu o prirode (sotsiologii) fenomena russkogo (rossiiskogo) patriotizma). Nizhegorodskii rakurs. Nizhnii Novgorod, Arabesk Publ., 2009, 112 p. (In Russian)
Belova I. Pervaia mirovaia voina i rossiiskaia provintsiia: 1914 — fevral’ 1917 g. Moscow, AIRO-XXI Publ.,2011, 283 p. (In Russian)
Benecke W. Militär, Reform und Gesellschaft im Zarenreich. Die Wehrpflicht in Russland 1874–1914. Paderborn,Ferdinand Schöningh, 2006, 440 S.
Benecke W. Zur Rolle der russisch-orthodoxen Militärgeistlichkeit vor 1914. Jahrbücher für Geschichte Osteuropas, 2004, Bd. 52, S. 371–87.
Beyrau D. Der Erste Weltkrieg als Bewährungsprobe. Bolschewistische Lernprozesse aus dem “imperialistischen” Krieg. Journal of Modern European History, 2003, vol. 1, pp. 96–124.
Beyrau D., Shcherbinin P. Alles für die Front: Russland im Krieg 1914–1922. Durchhalten! Krieg und Gesellschaft
im Vergleich 1914–1918. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2010, S. 151–177.
Bunin A. Iu. Deiatel’nost’ pravoslavnogo dukhovenstva Kurskogo kraia v 1905–1929 gg. PhD diss. (History). Kursk, Kurskii gosudarstvennyi universitet, 2005, 228 p. (In Russian)
Chernozerskii V. So s”ezda dukhovenstva i mirian 8–13 avgusta. Penzenskie eparkhial’nye vedomosti, 1917, no. 18 (20 August), p. 567 (In Russian)
Cohen A. Oh, That! Myth, Memory, and World War I in the Russian Emigration and the Soviet Union.Slavic Review, 2003, vol. 62, pp. 69–86.
Colpe C. Der “Heilige Krieg”. Benennung und Wirklichkeit, Begründung und Widerstreit. Bodenheim, 1994, 98 S.
Culture Matters. Eds S. Hungtington, L. Harrison. New York, Basic Books Publ., 2000, 348 p.
Davis G. H. National Red Cross Societies and Prisoners of War in Russia, 1914–1918. Journal of Contemporary History, 1993, vol. 28, pp. 31–52.
Firsov S. L. Russkaia tserkov’ nakanune peremen (konets XIX v. — 1918 gg.). Moscow, Kruglyi stol po religioznomu obrazovaniiu i diakonii Publ., 2002, 623 p.
Freeze G. L. All Power to the Parish? The Problem and Politics of Church Reform in Late Imperial Russia. Social Identities in Revolutionary Russia. London, Macmillan Publ., 2001, pp. 174–208.
Freeze G. L. From Dechristianization to Laicization: State, Church, and Believers in Russia. Canadian Slavonic Papers, 2015, vol. 57, pp. 6–34.
Freeze G. L. Vladimirskaia eparkhiia: ot tserkovnoi k prikhodskoi revoliutsii. Konfessional’naia politika Sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1920–1950e gody. Moscow, ROSSPEN Publ., 2019, pp. 6–16. (In Russian)
Freeze G. L. Voina i reforma: Russkaia pravoslavnaia tserkov’ v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny, 1914–1917 gg. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2015, issue 1, pp. 90–116. (In Russian)
Freeze G. L. Votserkovlenie 1917 goda: tserkovnyi krizis i prikhodskaia revoliutsiia. Gosudarstvo, tserkov’,religiia v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2019, no. 1/2, pp. 30–57. (In Russian)
Freeze G. L. Vsia vlast’ prikhodam: vozrozhdenie pravoslaviia v 1920-e gody. Gosudarstvo, religiia i tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2012, no. 3–4, pp. 86–105. (In Russian)
Gross G. P. Die vergessene Front — der Osten, 1914/15: Ereignis, Wirkung, Nachwirkung. Paderborn, Schönungh, 2006, 414 S.
Hirschfeld G. Germany. Companion to World War I. Oxford, Blackwell Publ., 2010, pp. 432–446.
Hoover A. J. God and Germany in the Great War: The View of the Protestant Pastors. Canadian Review of Nationalities, 1987, vol. 14, pp. 65–81.
Hürten H. Die Kirchen in der Novemberrevolution. Eine Untersuchung zur Geschichte der deutschen Revolution 1918/19. Regensburg, F. Pustet Publ., 1984, 178 p.
Iakhontov A. Ia. Tiazhelye dni. Arkhiv russkoi revoliutsii, vol. 18. Berlin, [s. n.], 1926, pp. 5–136. (In Russian)
Iurganova I. I. Iakutskaia dukhovnaia konsistoriia: istoriia stanovleniia i deiatel’nosti, 1870–1919 gg. PhD diss. (History). Yakutsk, Institut gumanitarnykh issledovanii Akademii nauk Respubliki Sakha Press, 2003, 237 p. (In Russian)
Izmozik V. S. K voprosu o politicheskikh nastroeniiakh rossiiskogo obshchestva v kanun 1917 g. (po materialam perliustatsii). Rossiia i Pervaia mirovaia voina. Materialy mezhdunarodnogo nauchnogo kollokviuma. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin Publ., 1999, pp. 160–171. (In Russian)
Jahn H. F. Patriotic Culture in Russia during World War I. Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 1995, 229 p.
Kail’ M. V. Smolenskaia eparkhiia nakanune revoliutsii. Dokumenty iz otcheta o sostoianii Smolenskoi eparkhii za 1916 g. Vestnik PSTGU, Istoriia RPTs, 2010, issue 3 (36), pp. 102–121. (In Russian)
Kandidov B. Tserkovnyi front v gody mirovoi voiny. Moscow, Tip. OGPU Publ., 1927, 147 p. (In Russian)
Kliuchareva A. V. Blagotvoritel’naia deiatel’nost’ pravoslavnykh monastyrei v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politekhnicheskie i iuridicheskoe nauki, 2011, no. 8 (14), сhast’ 2, pp. 98–102.(In Russian)
Leont’eva T. G. ‘Revoliutsionnaia tserkov’ ili ‘tserkovnaia revoliutsiia’? O nekotorykh noveishikh issledovaniiakh po istorii Russkoi pravoslavnoi tserkvi v 1917 g. Soviet and Post-Soviet Review, 2009, vol. 36, pp. 182–195. (In Russian)
Leont’eva T. G. Dukhovenstvo i sel’skii mir. 1905–1922. Akademik P. V. Volobuev: neopublikovannye raboty, vospominaniia, stat’i. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 2000, pp. 279–299. (In Russian)
Leont’eva T. G. Pravoslavnoe dukhovenstvo v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Rossiia i sovremennyi mir, 2014, no. 2 (83), pp. 104–119. (In Russian)
Lisitsyna O. L. K voprosu ob organizatsii blagotvoritel’noi i patrioticheskoi deiatel’nosti tul’skogo dukhovenstva gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Izvestiia Tul’lskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, Gumanitarnye nauki, 2013, no. 3 (1), pp. 93–102. (In Russian)
Lohr E. Russia. Companion to World War I. Oxford, Blackwell, 2010, pp. 479–93.
Lokteva N. A. Frontovye pis’ma kak istochnik dlia izucheniia moral’nogo i patrioticheskogo dukha soldat Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Posledniaia voina Rossiiskoi Imperii. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 2006, pp. 100–107.(In Russian)
Madigan E. Faith under Fire: Anglican Army Chaplains and the Great War. New York, Palgrave MacMillan,2011, 296 p.
Markevich A., Harrison M. Great War, Civil War, and Recovery: Russia’s National Income, 1913 to 1928. Journal of Economic History, 2011, vol. 71, pp. 672–703.
Meier K. Evangelische Kirche und Erster Weltkrieg. Der Erste Weltkrieg: Wirkung, Wahrnehmung, Analyse. Weyarn, Seehamer Verlag GmbH, 1997, S. 691–724.
Meteling W. Neue Forschung zum Ersten Weltkrieg: Englisch- und französischesprachige Studien über Deutschland, Frankreich und Großbritanien. Geschichte und Gesellschaft, 2011, Bd. 37, S. 614–648.
Mikhailov A. Pskov v gody Pervoi mirovoi voine 1914–1915 gg. Pskov, Dom Pechati Publ., 2012, 342 p. (In Russian)
Missalla H. “Gott mit Uns.” Die deutsche katholische Kriegspredigt 1914–1918. Munich, Kösel-Verlag, 1968,142 S.
Mommsen W. J. Die nationalgeschichtliche Umdeutung der christlichen Botschaft im Ersten Weltkrieg.“Gott mit uns”: Nation, Religion und Gewalt im 19. Und frühen 20. Jahrhundert. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck& Ruprecht, 2000, S. 249–261.
Narskii I. V. The Frontline Experience of Russian Soldiers in 1914–16. Russian Studies in History, 2013,vol. 41, pp. 31–49.
Nechaev M. G. Tserkov’ na Urale v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Tekhnologos, 2011, no. 4, pp. 61–75. (In Russian)
Porshneva O. S. Sotsial’noe povedenie soldat russkoi armii v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Sotsial’naia istoriia: ezhegodnik 2001/2002, Moscow, 2003, pp. 355–398. (In Russian)
Poverantsev I. Chrezvychainaia dorogovizna i dukhovenstva. Penzenskie eparkhial’nye vedomosti, 1917, no. 6 (16 March), pp. 183–188. (In Russian)
Pressel W. Die Kriegspredigt 1914–1918 in der evangelischen Kirche Deutschlands. Göttingen, Vandenhoeck& Ruprecht, 1967, 379 S.
Purseigle P. A Very French Debate: the 1914–1918 ’War Culture’. Journal of War and Culture Studies, 2008, vol. 1, pp. 9–14.
Rosenberg W. G. Reading Soldiers’ Moods: Russian Military Censorship and the Configuration of Feeling in World War I. American Historical Review, 2014, vol. 119, pp. 714–740.
Rossiia v Pervoi mirovoi: Velikaia zabytaia voina. Ed. by A. A. Klimov. Moscow, Iauza Publ., 2014, 542 p.(In Russian)
Rozhkov V. Tserkovnye voprosy v Gosudarstvennoi Dume. Moscow, Krutitskoe podvor’e Publ., 2004, 561 p.(In Russian)
Runkevich S. G. Velikaia Otechestvennaia voina i tserkovnaia zhizn’, vol. 1. Petrograd, 1916, 355 p. (In Russian)
Safonov A. A. Svoboda sovesti i modernizatsiia veroispovednogo zakonodatel’stva Rossiiskoi imperii v nachale XX v. Tambov, Pershina Publ., 2007, 367 p. (In Russian)
Sanborn J. The Mobilization of 1914 and the Question of the Russian Nation: A Reexamination. Slavic Review,2000, vol. 59, pp. 267–289.
Smith J. T. Russian Military Censorship during the First World War. Revolutionary Russia, 2001, vol. 14,pp. 71–95.
Snape M. The Great War. Cambridge History of Christianity, vol. 9. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2006, pp. 131–150.
Sokolov A. V. Solidarnost’ trudiashchikhsia ili vernost’ tserkvi? K voprosu o professional’nom dvizhenii sluzhashchikh i rabochikh dukhovnogo vedomstva v 1917 — nachale 1918 g. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, Seriia: Istoriia, 2016, no. 3, pp. 59–72. (In Russian)
Verhey J. Spirit of 1914: Militarism, Myth, and Mobilization in Germany. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2000, 284 p.
Waddel P. Guns, Gore and God: Bishop Gore and the First World War. Journal of Anglican Studie, 2017,vol. 15, pp. 88–107
Watson A. Enduring the Great War: Combat, Morale and Collapse in the German and British Armies 1914–1918. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2008, 288 p.
Winter J. Demography. Companion to World War I. Oxford, Blackwell, 2010, pp. 248–262.
Downloads
Published
2023-04-05
How to Cite
Freeze, G. L. (2023). Imperial Russia as a Failed State: The Role of Orthodox Church. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History, 68(1), 67–81. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu02.2023.104
Issue
Section
Discussions
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. History" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
